A Farmer’s Encounter with the Grim Reaper
In a fictional submission to the Signal Tribune’s 2026 Scary Story Contest, a Long Beach resident recounts a surreal and haunting experience involving the Grim Reaper and a dying horse.
A Long Beach resident, Evan Baughfman, submitted a story to the Signal Tribune’s 2026 Scary Story Contest that details a bizarre and unsettling encounter with the Grim Reaper. The narrative begins with the protagonist, armed with a pistol, heading to the stable where his horse, Avalanche, had died due to the prolonged drought (Source ID: 1). The protagonist had been struggling with the drought, which had made it difficult to sustain Avalanche, and had delayed putting him down due to the emotional attachment he had with the animal. [1]
Upon arriving at the stable, the protagonist discovers the Grim Reaper sitting in Avalanche’s stall, suffering from injuries inflicted by the horse. The Reaper explains that Avalanche had lashed out in self-defense, breaking the Reaper’s spine and rendering him unable to perform his duties (Source ID: 1). The Reaper pleads with the protagonist to kill him, offering the protagonist a scythe that had been broken during the encounter. The Reaper claims that the protagonist, as a farmer, is the perfect candidate to replace him in his role. [1]
The protagonist, burdened by the recent deaths of his family and the loss of his home, is confronted with the Reaper’s request. The Reaper suggests that the protagonist, who has already made the difficult decision to end the life of his horse, is capable of ending his own life, but instead offers the protagonist the opportunity to take on the Reaper’s role (Source ID: 1). The story concludes with the protagonist accepting the scythe, killing the Reaper, and being transformed into a new figure of death, riding off into the rain with his resurrected horse. [1]
The story was submitted by Evan Baughfman, a resident of Long Beach, as part of the Signal Tribune’s 2026 Scary Story Contest. The narrative takes place on a farm located in the area around Long Beach, with specific reference to a stable and a large wheat field. The farm is described as experiencing a severe drought, with the wheat field depicted as an expanse of dry, cracked earth that has not received rain for twenty months. The stable, where the story’s central events occur, is noted for its weathered hinges, indicating the passage of time and neglect. The farm has a long history of agricultural activity, with the protagonist having raised Avalanche, a white Clydesdale plow horse, from a foal into an adult. The stable is the location where the protagonist discovers the Grim Reaper, who claims to have been injured by Avalanche and requests the protagonist’s help. This setting provides a bleak and isolated backdrop for the story’s supernatural elements. [1]
Advertisement
The project scope of the story involves the protagonist’s journey from a state of personal grief and hardship to taking on the role of the Grim Reaper. The story spans a short but intense timeline, beginning with the discovery of the Reaper in the stable and culminating in the protagonist’s transformation into a new embodiment of death. The narrative does not focus on a physical construction or engineering project, but rather on a metaphysical and emotional transformation. The protagonist’s decision to accept the Reaper’s offer is framed as a culmination of his life experiences, including the death of his wife and sons, the loss of his home, and the suffering caused by the drought. These events collectively shape the protagonist’s readiness to embrace his new role. The story’s scope is limited to the farm and the immediate aftermath of the protagonist’s transformation, with no indication of broader societal or environmental implications beyond the farm’s immediate surroundings. [1]
The history of the farm is marked by the long-term relationship between the protagonist and Avalanche, the Clydesdale plow horse. The horse was raised from a foal and had been a central part of the farm’s operations. The protagonist’s emotional attachment to the horse is evident, as he expresses regret over not having euthanized the animal earlier due to the hardships of the drought. The farm’s history is also intertwined with the protagonist’s personal life, including the death of his wife and children, which is referenced as a contributing factor to his current state of despair. The farm has been a place of both labor and sorrow, with the protagonist having participated in the deaths of many livestock over the years. The farm’s history is further defined by the supernatural encounter with the Grim Reaper, an event that marks a turning point in the protagonist’s life and the farm’s fate. [1]
The documented limits of the story are primarily confined to the farm and its immediate surroundings. The narrative does not extend beyond the farm’s boundaries, with no mention of other locations or characters outside of the stable, the wheat field, and the protagonist’s home. The story’s supernatural elements are limited to the encounter with the Grim Reaper, who appears in the stable and interacts with the protagonist. The transformation of the protagonist into the new Grim Reaper is also confined to the farm setting, with no indication of the character’s influence beyond the farm. The limits of the story’s scope are further defined by the protagonist’s personal experiences, which are centered on his life on the farm, the death of his family, and his emotional response to these events. The story does not explore the broader implications of the protagonist’s transformation, focusing instead on the immediate consequences of his decision to accept the Reaper’s offer. [1]
A Long Beach resident, Evan Baughfman, submitted a story to the Signal Tribune’s 2026 Scary Story Contest that details a bizarre and unsettling encounter with the Grim Reaper. Upon arriving at the stable, the protagonist discovers the Grim Reaper sitting in Avalanche’s stall, suffering from injuries inflicted by the horse. The protagonist, burdened by the recent deaths of his family and the loss of his home, is confronted with the Reaper’s request. [1]
Advertisement
The protagonist finds Avalanche, his white Clydesdale plow horse, dead in the stall, with maggots already present around its vacant eyes. The stable doors creak on weathered hinges, and the protagonist recalls the difficulty of feeding and watering the horse during the ongoing drought. The Reaper appears from the shadows, explaining that Avalanche had lashed out and broken its spine, and now requests the protagonist’s help to end its suffering. [1]
The Reaper explains that it had come to the stable hoping to gain another equine companion, but Avalanche had resisted its offer and instead attacked it. The Reaper now asks the protagonist to kill it, stating that the only way it can die is by being struck down with its own blade. The protagonist, struggling with the loss of his family and his home, is confronted with the Reaper’s plea for mercy and the possibility of taking on the Reaper’s role as the bringer of death. [1]
The protagonist ultimately agrees to the Reaper’s request, taking the broken scythe and using it to end the Reaper’s life. After the Reaper’s death, the protagonist is transformed, taking on the Reaper’s robes and scythe, and riding off with Avalanche, who is mysteriously revived by the rain that follows. The story ends with the protagonist now tasked with fulfilling the Reaper’s former duties. [1]
Sources
Prepared with AI assistance from the cited sources.
The Cali Reporter newsletter
The stories worth your time.
California, the country, and what comes next. Join our free newsletter for reporting that keeps you informed.
More in Long Beach
- Musical Theatre West Presents 'Little Women: The Musical'
Musical Theatre West (MTW) will present a musical adaptation of 'Little Women' at the Carpenter Performing Arts Center from November 6 to 22, 2026, as part of its 2026 season.
- Browning High School Students Gain Workforce Experience Through First Course Program
Ten students from Browning High School are participating in the First Course Workforce Development program at Wrigley Coffee, gaining hands-on training and mentorship in a real-world café environment.
- Little Women: The Musical Revitalizes a Classic Story
A review of 'Little Women: The Musical' highlights the performances, set design, and emotional depth of the production at the Carpenter Performing Arts Center.